Showing posts with label Navigation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Navigation. Show all posts

Sunday, July 23, 2006

Garmin 2730 and Traffic Data

After being without my bike for so long, I'd rather ride than write (most of the time). Ah, summer!

Last night I went into Chicago for theatre and dinner. As usual, I let my Garmin 2730 guide me (it has GPS and integrates traffic information). It was late on a Saturday afternoon. Despite my disbelief, I followed its route. I don't know why it was routing me away from the expressways. After a time, I insisted and headed towards I94 (and am glad - shaved 10 minutes off my ETA time in a very short time ). At one point (a little early) it routed me off of I94 onto Skokie Blvd. Assuming a bottleneck, I complied, but after a bit of traffic, I repented and found my way back to I94. It was moving quite well. I was able to make up _some_ of the lost time, but I was about 5 minutes late instad of 15+ minutes early. Down in the city, Garmin suggested an exit that I _did_ finally take (could see the congestion ahead).

So - what is the problem?
  • Is the traffic data not correct / sufficient as fed through the satellite feeds?
  • Is the software doing too much generalization (a bottleneck somewhere on 94? stay off of ALL of 94).
  • Why is the software not choosing shortest time (we're talking 25% off here - it's significant!)?
From now on, I'll pick the best / fastest route I know from experience, and ignore the Garmin - unless I see visual confirmation.

As for out of town - well, I'll at least it always seems to get me to the correct place.